Home » Judgments » Family Courts Act 1964 » s.17
Judgments on s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
Pakistani court judgments that consider s.17, Family Courts Act 1964, summarised in plain English, newest first. Each gives the issue, what the court held and what it means in practice, and is reviewed by an advocate.
7 judgments
To recover gold, the wife must prove the husband’s side kept it, not only that it was given
Mohsin Ali v. Mst. Sidra Bibi, etc.
Issue: Can a decree for six tolas of gold ornaments stand on proof, or an apparent admission, that gold was given to the…
Held: No. Giving the ornaments and their later snatching or retention are separate facts, each needing proof. A suggestion put to and denied by the husband's witness is not an admission; and the husband's failure to prove he was away from…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
Dowry delivery must be proved; custom and purchase receipts are not enough
Farrukh Altaf v. Mst. Sadia Anam etc.
Issue: Can the custom of giving dowry, an itemised inventory and purchase receipts prove that particular dowry articles were delivered to the husband's…
Held: No, not by themselves. Section 17 relaxes the rules of proof but does not dispense with proof: credible oral evidence can establish a dowry claim without receipts, but the court must still find that the particular articles were delivered. Here…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
A prompt-dower entry proves the promise, not that payment was made
Mst. Amna Shaikh v. Imran Ahmed Shaikh and another
Issue: On khula, must a wife return dower that the Nikahnama records as prompt but which the husband cannot prove he paid; and…
Held: No. A Nikahnama entry that dower is prompt proves the obligation, not its payment; the husband who pleads payment must prove it, and the proviso to section 10(4) of the Family Courts Act requires restoration only of dower 'received by…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973s.10, Muslim Family Laws Ordinance 1961s.10(4), Family Courts Act 1964s.14(2)(a), Family Courts Act 1964
Parents cannot bargain away a child’s independent right to maintenance
Mst. Shazia Naureen, etc. v. District Judge, etc.
Issue: Can a mother, as guardian, agree to reduced maintenance for her children, and can a Family Court fix the children's maintenance solely…
Held: No to both. A child's right to maintenance belongs to the child, not the parent; a guardian cannot waive, reduce or surrender it, and any agreement doing so is void against the minor. A compromise on a minor's behalf needs…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973O.XXXII, Code of Civil Procedure 1908s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
Military pension can be attached to enforce a final child-maintenance decree
Muhammad Latif v. Addl. District Judge, Jaranwala etc.
Issue: Can the pension of a retired Army official be attached to enforce a final Family Court decree for his children's maintenance, despite…
Held: Yes. Section 11 of the Pensions Act protects pensions from attachment 'at the instance of a creditor', but minor children enforcing their father's duty to maintain them are not creditors and the liability is not an ordinary debt. Section 171…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973s.11, Pensions Act 1871s.13, Family Courts Act 1964s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
Family cases must move fast: the court orders reports on suits pending over six months
Muhammad Iqbal Afzal v. Judge Family Court, etc.
Issue: Was the Family Court right to close a defendant husband's evidence after repeated warnings, in a khula, dowry and maintenance suit pending…
Held: Yes. The order sheets showed clear warnings and a last chance, and repeated dilatory tactics; fair hearing means a reasonable opportunity, not endless adjournments. The petition was dismissed and the Family Court directed to finish the case day to day…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973s.12-A, Family Courts Act 1964s.17, Family Courts Act 1964
Foreign maintenance orders: avoiding a duplicate child-maintenance claim in Pakistan
Muhammad Muneeb Arshad v. Mst. Ammara Mahroof and others
Issue: Where an Irish court has already fixed a child's maintenance and the father is paying it, can a Pakistani Family Court run…
Held: No, on these facts. Living abroad does not by itself oust a Pakistani Family Court's jurisdiction under Rule 6, but where a competent foreign court has fixed the child's maintenance and it is being paid, the same claim cannot run…
Art. 199, Constitution of Pakistan 1973r.6, Family Courts Rules 1965s.10, Code of Civil Procedure 1908s.11, Code of Civil Procedure 1908
