Home » Judgments » Sindh High Court
Prove limited means with records before challenging interim maintenance
Sakib Ali Mahesar v. Faria Khan Laghari and others Sindh High Court C.P. No. S-397 of 2025 Unreported Decided Justice Abdul Hamid Bhurgri (Karachi)
Judgment at a glance
- Legal issue
- Can a father use Article 199 to overturn interim child maintenance of Rs. 150,000 a month by saying his income is only Rs. 800,000 a year, without producing any records?
- Decision
- No. Interim maintenance orders are not open to appeal or revision, so Article 199 is available only for lack of jurisdiction, mala fides or patent illegality, none of which was shown. The mother produced documents showing a petrol pump, agricultural land and housing-scheme interests; the father produced nothing, not even tax returns. The petition was dismissed with directions to adjust payments, calculate arrears and decide the maintenance application within two months.
- Key principle
- Because interim maintenance orders under section 17-A are excluded from appeal and revision by section 14(3) of the Family Courts Act, they can be challenged under Article 199 only for lack of jurisdiction, mala fides or patent illegality; disputed income and assets must be tested by evidence at trial.
- Outcome
- Dismissed
- Relevant law
- Family Courts Act 1964, ss.14(3) and 17-A; Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 199
- Why it matters
- A parent who says interim maintenance is too high must bring records (tax returns, accounts, property papers); a bare claim of low income will fail.
- Interim maintenance orders usually cannot be challenged in the High Court; the place to contest income is the Family Court trial.
Cite as: Sakib Ali Mahesar v. Faria Khan Laghari and others, Sindh High Court, C.P. No. S-397 of 2025, decided 21 September 2026
Facts
From the judgment
On 30 April 2025 the XIXth Family Judge, Karachi South, deciding an application under section 17-A, fixed interim maintenance for the child at Rs. 150,000 a month from May 2025. (para 1)
The father said this was excessive because his income was Rs. 800,000 a year. The mother objected under section 14(3) and produced documents and photographs showing that he owned a petrol pump, agricultural land and interests in housing schemes. (para 2)
An earlier High Court interim order of 8 April 2026 had required him to pay Rs. 50,000 a month from 1 July 2025. (para 7)
Procedural history
From the judgment
- 30 April 2025Family Suit No. 323 of 2025; application under s.17-A, XIXth Family Judge, District South, KarachiInterim child maintenance fixed at Rs. 150,000 a month from May 2025 (para 1)
- 8 April 2026C.P. No. S-397 of 2025 (interim order), Sindh High Court, KarachiFather to pay Rs. 50,000 a month from 1 July 2025 meanwhile (para 7)
- 21 September 2026C.P. No. S-397 of 2025, Sindh High Court, KarachiDismissed; interim order maintained; payments to be adjusted and arrears calculated and paid; maintenance application to be decided within two months (para 6-11)
Questions of law
Can an interim maintenance order under section 17-A be challenged under Article 199 on the ground that the amount is excessive? Our framing
The court's answer: Only for lack of jurisdiction, mala fides or patent illegality, because the statute bars appeal and revision; an unsupported claim of low income shows none of these. (para 4-5)
Arguments
From the judgment
Petitioner or appellant
The interim maintenance was excessive because his income was Rs. 800,000 a year (para 2).
Respondent
The petition was barred by section 14(3) of the Family Courts Act; documents and photographs showed he owned a petrol pump, agricultural land and interests in housing schemes (para 2).
Court's reasoning
From the judgment
Interim orders and Article 199
The order was interim and the legislature has barred appeal and revision against such orders, so constitutional jurisdiction cannot substitute for remedies the statute has withheld. It can be invoked only for lack of jurisdiction, mala fides or patent illegality (Arif Fareed, 2023 SCMR 413; Hammad Hassan, 2023 SCMR 1434), and none was shown. (para 4)
No records from the father
Prima facie the mother's documents showed assets and the means to pay. The father produced nothing in rebuttal, not even income tax returns for his claimed Rs. 800,000 a year. His income and assets were disputed facts needing evidence, which cannot be recorded in constitutional jurisdiction; the trial court's order was itself tentative. (para 5)
Directions
The petition was dismissed. Amounts paid under the High Court's interim order of Rs. 50,000 a month are to be adjusted against Rs. 150,000 a month from May 2025; the Family Court must calculate the balance within 15 days and the father pay it within 30 days, failing which recovery may be ordered. He must keep depositing Rs. 150,000 by the 14th of each month, and the Family Court should decide the maintenance application within two months. Nothing was decided on merits. (para 6-12)
Judicial observations
From the judgment
The court's exact words.
It cannot be used as a substitute for the remedies the statute has withheld.
Case details
- Case
- Sakib Ali Mahesar v. Faria Khan Laghari and others
- Court
- Sindh High Court
- Bench
- Justice Abdul Hamid Bhurgri (Karachi)
- Date of decision
- Case number
- C.P. No. S-397 of 2025
- Citation
- None known (unreported)
- Outcome
- Dismissed
- Statutes considered
- Family Courts Act 1964, ss.14(3) and 17-A; Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 199
- Topics
- Maintenance
Practical implications
Our analysis
For lawyers
- Before challenging interim maintenance, assemble documentary proof of income: tax returns, salary or business accounts, bank statements.
- Remember section 14(3) bars appeal and revision against interim orders; a writ needs a jurisdictional defect, mala fides or patent illegality.
- For the claimant: put property and business records on file early; they carried the day here even at the interim stage.
- Expect payments made under a High Court interim order to be adjusted, and arrears to be calculated and enforced on a short timetable.
For everyone else
- If you say you cannot afford the interim maintenance, you must show proof such as tax returns or accounts; just saying your income is low is not enough.
- Interim maintenance orders usually cannot be appealed. Arguments about how much you earn are decided at the Family Court trial.
General points drawn from this judgment, not advice on your own case.
Limits of this judgment
Our analysis
- An interim stage: the Court expressly decided nothing on merits, and its observations are tentative (para 12).
- It does not say whether Rs. 150,000 a month is the right final amount; that is for the Family Court.
Questions about this case
Can I challenge interim maintenance in the High Court?
Only in narrow cases: lack of jurisdiction, mala fides or patent illegality. Appeal and revision against interim orders are barred (para 4).
What evidence of income should I produce?
Documents. The father here lost partly because he did not even file his income tax returns, while the mother showed his property and business (para 5).
Sources
- Official text
- Judgment PDF (court website)
- Our saved copy
- PDF, saved
- How this summary was made
- Summary from the full judgment
- Official text read on
- Note on the text
- Heard and decided on 21 September 2026. The order describes itself as an order on the petition; the earlier record called it an 'interim order', but it finally disposed of the petition. No reported citation appears in the court's text.
- Cite this summary
- PK-Legal & Associates, "Prove limited means with records before challenging interim maintenance", summary of Sakib Ali Mahesar v. Faria Khan Laghari and others, Sindh High Court, C.P. No. S-397 of 2025, decided 21 September 2026, https://pklegal.org/judgments/shc-2026-s397-interim-maintenance/ (reviewed 3 November 2026).
