Skip to content
Mon–Sat, 9:00 AM – 10:00 PM0331 9999 129 Book a consultation

PK-Legal Weekly Law Briefing

Grandfather’s Interim Maintenance, Habeas Corpus in Custody Disputes and the Proposed Family Courts Bill — Family Law Brief

Can a grandfather be ordered to pay interim maintenance for his grandchild in Pakistan? A Sindh High Court order says yes where the father has died and the grandfather appears able to pay. A second order explains why parental custody disputes belong in the Guardian Court, not habeas corpus, and the Law and Justice Commission has published a proposed Family Courts Bill.

Weekly edition

Maintenance · Grandfather liability · Custody · Habeas corpus · Law reform

3

Two Sindh High Court orders and one reform report

Both orders were passed on 16 November 2026 at the Circuit Court, Larkana. The third item is Law Reform Report No. 144 of the Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan.

—

Important limits

Both orders are single-judge orders, and the official copies show no reporter citation. The Family Courts Bill is a proposal, not law. In our review, we found no new Supreme Court ruling on family law and no new authority on khula or the talaq notice under section 7 of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961.

Weekly analysis · Pakistan family law

Can a grandfather be made to pay maintenance for his grandchild in Pakistan?

Yes, in the right facts. The Supreme Court held in Bashir Ahmad v. Additional District Judge, Hafizabad (PLD 2024 SC 67) that when a child’s father has died or has no means, the duty to maintain the child passes to the grandfather, if he is in easy circumstances. On 16 November 2026 the Sindh High Court applied that rule and left in place a Family Court order for Rs. 20,000 a month in interim maintenance against a paternal grandfather.

The same judge, on the same day, refused to use habeas corpus to return three children to their father. The children were with their mother, who had already applied to the Guardian Court. Both orders point litigants back to the forum the law provides: the Family Court for maintenance and the Guardian Court for custody.

Sindh High Court · Circuit Court, Larkana · Single-judge order

Grandfather may be ordered to pay interim maintenance for his late son’s child

Inayatullah Bhutto v. Civil/Family Judge-III, Larkana and another, C.P. No. S-371 of 2026, order dated 16 November 2026 — Sindh High Court, Circuit Court, Larkana, Arbab Ali Hakro, J.

Court

Sindh High Court, Circuit Court, Larkana

Bench

Justice Arbab Ali Hakro

Date

Status

Petition dismissed; no reporter citation on the official copy

The holding in one sentence

An interim maintenance order under section 17-A of the Family Courts Act, 1964 cannot be appealed or revised because of section 14(3), and the High Court will not interfere under Article 199 unless the order is without jurisdiction or disregards the statute, which this order against a grandfather did not.

The child’s father died in July 2023. The mother, who has custody under a Guardian Court order, sued the paternal grandfather for maintenance, pleading that he holds the shops and building left by his son and collects their rent. During the suit, the Family Court ordered the grandfather to pay Rs. 20,000 a month for the child until the suit is decided. The grandfather challenged that order in the High Court.

01

Article 199 cannot reopen a door that section 14(3) closes

Section 14(3) bars an appeal or revision against an interim order of a Family Court. Relying on Khalid Pervaiz ul Haq v. Mst. Minha Asif (PLD 2025 SC 847) and President All Pakistan Women Association v. Muhammad Akbar Awan (2020 SCMR 260), the Court held that a barred remedy cannot be sought indirectly through a writ petition.

02

The grandfather’s liability, prima facie

Following Bashir Ahmad (PLD 2024 SC 67), a Family Court may order interim maintenance against a grandfather if it is prima facie satisfied that the father has died or has no means, and that the grandfather is in easy circumstances. The father’s death was admitted here.

03

His own words counted against him

The Family Court relied on the property documents on its file. The High Court added that the grandfather had told the Guardian Court he was financially sound and able to provide for the child, and his written statement did not deny that the deceased’s property was let out.

04

Disputing the court’s record needs counsel’s affidavit

The order recorded that both sides were present and heard. Following Syed Ali Ahmed Shah v. Syed Shoukat Hussain Shah (2025 SCMR 361), a claim that contradicts the court’s record, without an affidavit from the counsel who attended, cannot upset the order.

Result and limits

The petition was dismissed. The interim order covers the child only. The Family Court left the disputed divorce and the final rate of maintenance for decision after evidence. The insurance money the mother received is a question of fact for trial. The pending civil suits over the son’s estate have no bearing on the child’s maintenance, which lies within the Family Court’s exclusive jurisdiction.

Drafting impact for maintenance claims against a grandfather

These are PK-Legal’s practical suggestions, not part of the order.

Plead both Bashir Ahmad conditions

State the father’s death or lack of means, and the grandfather’s capacity: named property, rent or business income, and other assets.

Use the connected record

Annex land, tenancy and revenue documents. Look for admissions in guardianship or civil proceedings, as the grandfather’s own statement mattered here.

Oppose with documents, not a bare plea

A grandfather resisting liability should file a detailed account of income and assets with supporting papers. A general plea of limited means is weak against documents on file.

Frame a writ only on jurisdiction

A challenge to an interim order must show it is without jurisdiction or disregards the statute. Disputing the amount or the evidence will not be enough.

For our earlier summary on the same question, see Grandfather’s maintenance: present capacity is separate from past liability and 2026 LHC 1151 on who pays child maintenance. For the wider law, see our wife and child maintenance guide and how child maintenance is calculated. Read the official SHC order (C.P. No. S-371 of 2026).

Sindh High Court · Circuit Court, Larkana · Single-judge order

Habeas corpus is not the ordinary route for a custody dispute between parents

Riyaz Ahmed Khoso v. Province of Sindh and others, C.P. No. S-365 of 2026, order dated 16 November 2026 — Sindh High Court, Circuit Court, Larkana, Arbab Ali Hakro, J.

Court

Sindh High Court, Circuit Court, Larkana

Bench

Justice Arbab Ali Hakro

Date

Status

Disposed of, with liberty to apply to the Guardian Court; no reporter citation on the official copy

The holding in one sentence

The High Court will not order children’s production under Article 199(1)(b)(i) in a dispute between parents unless they are of very tender age, were recently snatched from lawful custody and the matter is truly urgent, because the Guardian Court is the forum for custody.

A father alleged that his three children were taken from his house by force in September 2026, and asked the High Court to have them recovered and returned to him. The police reported that the children had been traced to their mother in Lahore. Within five days of the alleged removal, she had applied to the Guardian Court under sections 7 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, with the children present. The children were about seventeen, ten and seven years old.

01

Habeas corpus between parents is exceptional

Following Mst. Nadia Perveen v. Mst. Almas Noreen (PLD 2012 SC 758), the writ is available only where the children are of very tender age, were recently snatched from lawful custody, and there is real urgency. The Guardian Judge can recover children and regulate interim custody.

02

A mother’s remarriage is a welfare factor, not a bar

Following Mst. Qurat-ul-Ain v. SHO, Police Station Saddar Jalalpur Jattan (2024 SCMR 486), a mother does not lose custody merely because she has remarried. Her custody is not without lawful authority for that reason alone. The Guardian Court weighs the remarriage as part of the children’s welfare.

03

Disputed facts need evidence, and the mother must be a party

The father said the children were taken by force, and the mother told the Guardian Court they were with her. That conflict cannot be resolved without evidence. No order about her custody could be made because she had not been made a respondent.

04

The remedies under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890

The father can object to territorial jurisdiction under section 9, seek production and temporary custody under section 12, or file his own application under section 25. The Guardian Court is best placed to secure the children’s presence and ascertain their wishes.

Result and limits

The petition was disposed of. The father may pursue his remedies before the Guardian Court of competent jurisdiction, and the investigation into his criminal complaint is to be completed according to law. The Court described its observations as tentative, not binding on the Guardian Court or the trial court.

Drafting impact for urgent custody cases

These are PK-Legal’s practical suggestions, not part of the order.

Plead the exception, if it exists

A habeas petition should show recent removal from lawful custody, the child’s tender age, real urgency or danger, and why the Guardian Court cannot give effective relief in time.

Name the parent who has the children

Make the parent holding the children a respondent. Without them, no order can be made about their custody.

Otherwise, go to the Guardian Court

File the main section 25 petition with a focused section 12 application, supported by school, residence and welfare evidence.

Raise jurisdiction early

If the other parent filed in a different city, consider a section 9 objection to territorial jurisdiction at the first hearing.

See our earlier summaries on habeas corpus while a custody case is pending and a mother’s remarriage and child custody, and our guides to recovering a child taken by the other parent and child custody and guardianship. Read the official SHC order (C.P. No. S-365 of 2026).

Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan · Proposal, not law

The proposed Family Courts Bill, 2026: what would change for maintenance, dowry and appeals

Law Reform Report No. 144, Proposed Family Courts Bill, 2026 — Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan. Forwarding approved at the Commission’s 50th meeting on 11 September 2026; the report’s PDF is dated 30 October 2026.

Issued by

Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan

Scope

Comprehensive reform of the Family Courts Act, 1964

Next step

Federal and provincial governments decide whether to legislate

Status

Not enacted; not binding

What it is in one sentence

A consolidated reform of the Family Courts Act, 1964, sent to the governments to amend the Act or legislate afresh, which would add specialised courts, compulsory financial disclosure, sworn dowry inventories, electronic procedure and a limited appeal on dower.

01

Specialised courts

Dedicated Family Courts and Family Appellate Courts, and specialised Family Benches in the High Courts.

02

Disclosure in maintenance suits

The defendant would file, with the written statement, an affidavit of income, assets, liabilities, bank accounts and other resources as at the date the suit was filed. A later transfer of an asset would not, by itself, take it out of account.

03

Sworn dowry inventories

Both sides would file inventories of dowry and personal property verified on oath, with purchase receipts, ownership documents, photographs and video where available. The inventory would form part of the pleadings.

04

Interim maintenance and annual increase

Interim maintenance would generally be payable from the date the suit was filed, with arrears allowed in instalments and consequences for default, including striking off the defence. Where a decree sets no annual increase, maintenance would rise by ten per cent a year, compounded.

05

Electronic procedure and enforcement

Electronic filing, records, service and video-link proceedings, and rules for executing decrees and attaching property in another district.

06

A limited appeal on dower

No appeal against dissolution itself, but an appeal on the grant, refusal, return, relinquishment or adjustment of dower above Rs. 100,000. Such an appeal would not affect the dissolution of the marriage.

How to use it now

Do not plead these provisions as existing rights. The Family Courts Act, 1964 still applies. The proposed disclosure and inventory rules are, however, a useful checklist today: an itemised, documented dowry list and a detailed account of the other side’s means make a stronger case under the current law.

For dowry claims under the current law, see our dowry articles recovery guide and last week’s brief on the effect of khula on dower and maintenance. Read the official LJCP report (PDF).

Reading order

Read first

1

Inayatullah Bhutto v. Civil/Family Judge-III, Larkana

Read paragraphs 7 to 8 on section 14(3) and the grandfather’s liability, and paragraph 9 on disputing the court’s record.

2

Riyaz Ahmed Khoso v. Province of Sindh

Read paragraphs 7 to 8 on the limits of habeas corpus between parents, and paragraph 10 on the remedies under sections 9, 12 and 25.

3

LJCP Law Reform Report No. 144

Read the foreword for the reform plan, then the proposed provisions on pleadings and interim maintenance. Watch for any government bill based on it.

Frequently asked questions

Grandfather maintenance, habeas corpus and the Family Courts Bill: common questions

Is a grandfather liable to maintain his grandchild in Pakistan?

He can be. Under Bashir Ahmad (PLD 2024 SC 67), the duty passes to the grandfather when the father has died or has no means, provided the grandfather is in easy circumstances. In C.P. No. S-371 of 2026, the Sindh High Court left an interim order of Rs. 20,000 a month against a grandfather in place on that basis.

Can an interim maintenance order of a Family Court be appealed?

No. Section 14(3) of the Family Courts Act, 1964 bars an appeal or revision against an interim order. A writ petition can succeed only if the order is without jurisdiction or disregards the statute. Otherwise, the point can be raised when the final decree is challenged.

Does pending litigation over the father’s estate stop the child’s maintenance claim?

Not in this case. The Sindh High Court held that pending civil suits about the deceased father’s estate had no bearing on the child’s maintenance, which is within the Family Court’s exclusive jurisdiction.

Can a father use habeas corpus to get his children back from their mother?

Only in exceptional cases: very young children, recently snatched from lawful custody, with real urgency. Otherwise the Guardian Court is the right forum. In C.P. No. S-365 of 2026, the children were about seventeen, ten and seven, were with their mother, and she had already applied to the Guardian Court, so the writ was refused.

Does a mother lose custody if she remarries?

Not automatically. Following Qurat-ul-Ain (2024 SCMR 486), the Sindh High Court said a mother does not lose custody merely because she has remarried. The Guardian Court weighs the remarriage as one factor in the child’s welfare.

Which sections of the Guardians and Wards Act apply in an urgent custody dispute?

Section 12 for production and temporary custody of the child, section 25 for permanent custody, and section 9 to object if the case was filed in the wrong place.

Is the Family Courts Bill, 2026 now law?

No. It is a proposal in Law Reform Report No. 144 of the Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan, sent to the federal and provincial governments for legislative action. The Family Courts Act, 1964 still applies.

Would the proposed bill increase maintenance every year?

Under the proposal, where a decree sets no annual increase, maintenance would rise by ten per cent a year on a compound basis. This is not yet law.

Need advice on maintenance from a grandfather or an urgent custody case?

Share your case history, the relevant orders and your city with PK-Legal & Associates for advice on your facts.

Discuss your family matter

Primary sources and related guidance

Checked on 20 November 2026. Both complete official SHC orders and the LJCP report were read. The case names, case numbers, dates, judge and the Supreme Court citations above are taken from the orders themselves. No reporter citation has been added for either order.

Editorial note · 20 November 2026: This briefing separates the courts’ orders from PK-Legal’s drafting suggestions. Both orders are single-judge orders that apply Supreme Court precedent, and the Family Courts Bill is only a proposal. Read the complete orders and check later treatment before relying on a proposition in a live matter. This article provides general legal information, not advice on a particular case.

Pakistan Family Law Brief

Court decisions, evidence preparation and practical drafting implications.

PK-Legal & Associates