Home » Judgments » Supreme Court of Pakistan
A High Court cannot rehear the facts of a family case under Article 199
M. Hamad Hassan v. Mst. Isma Bukhari and 2 others Supreme Court of Pakistan Civil Petition No. 1418 of 2023 2023 SCMR 1434 Decided Justice Ayesha A. Malik (author) and Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi
Judgment at a glance
- Legal issue
- When a family suit has been decided by the trial court and the appellate court, can a High Court re-examine the facts in a writ petition under Article 199?
- Decision
- No. The wife and minor son's suit for dower, maintenance and dowry articles was decreed, and the appellate court upheld it and raised the annual increase in maintenance from 10% to 20%. The husband's writ petition raised only factual grounds, and the High Court, though it dismissed the petition, treated those grounds as an appeal and decided the dispute on the facts. Reviewing its earlier cases, including Shajar Islam (PLD 2007 SC 45), Tayyeba Ambareen (2023 SCMR 246) and Arif Fareed (2023 SCMR 413), the Supreme Court held that the constitutional jurisdiction cannot replace a revision or an appeal. A High Court cannot reappraise the evidence and decide a case on its facts. It may step in only on limited grounds, such as misreading or non-reading of evidence, or an order that is arbitrary, perverse or against the law. The High Court's approach was an error, amounting to an appeal against the appellate court's judgment. The petition was dismissed and leave refused.
- Key principle
- The right of appeal is created by statute, and where the legislature gave no second appeal, the appellate court's decision on the facts is final; a High Court under Article 199 corrects jurisdictional errors and procedural illegality, and interference is the exception, not the rule.
- Outcome
- Dismissed
- Relevant law
- Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 199; Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 185(3); Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 4
- Why it matters
- After the appellate court decides a family case, a writ petition is not a second chance to argue the facts.
- A writ petition should identify a jurisdictional defect, a misreading of evidence or a legal error, not simply disagree with the findings.
- Decree holders can rely on this judgment to resist writ petitions that reargue the evidence.
Cite as: M. Hamad Hassan v. Mst. Isma Bukhari and 2 others, 2023 SCMR 1434, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Civil Petition No. 1418 of 2023, decided 17 July 2023
Case details
- Case
- M. Hamad Hassan v. Mst. Isma Bukhari and 2 others
- Bench
- Justice Ayesha A. Malik (author) and Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi
- Date of decision
- Case number
- Civil Petition No. 1418 of 2023
- Citation
- 2023 SCMR 1434
- Outcome
- Dismissed
- Statutes considered
- Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 199; Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 185(3); Constitution of Pakistan 1973, Art. 4
- Topics
- Dower, Dowry, Maintenance
Sources
- Official text
- Judgment PDF (court website)
- Our saved copy
- PDF, saved
- How this summary was made
- Summary from the full judgment
- Official text read on
- Note on the text
- The trial court decreed the suit on 24 November 2018 and the appellate court decided the appeal on 24 May 2019. The Peshawar High Court dismissed the writ petition on 16 December 2022. The hearing and the judgment are both dated 17 July 2023. Approved for reporting. The citation 2023 SCMR 1434 is taken from the Supreme Court's own reference to this judgment in Ibrahim Khan v. Mst. Saima Khan and others. Short summary checked against the judgment.
- Cite this summary
- PK-Legal & Associates, "A High Court cannot rehear the facts of a family case under Article 199", summary of M. Hamad Hassan v. Mst. Isma Bukhari and 2 others, 2023 SCMR 1434, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Civil Petition No. 1418 of 2023, decided 17 July 2023, https://pklegal.org/judgments/sc-2023-1418-no-reappraisal-article-199/ (reviewed 6 November 2026).
